September 5. Mia’s death – a clear tragedy and strategically placed. We have grown attached enough to her in the brief tutorial case that the murder is a shocking, unexpected atrocity of moral outrage with emotive impact – but not attached enough to be so emotionally devastating it detracts from the main story of the living – and the hence-unexpected ‘resurrection’ (and finishing Mia’s mission) marks the case as a triumph over White’s injustice (even if Mia in the games is still bittersweet henceforth.) A tragic tale – but for the main story and protagonists, really only the beginning. And the facilitation of Mia’s career goal coming to fruition is entirely by reciprocal virtue of a new bond formed that terrible night.
---
A summary of key observations from the Phoenix-Maya intro case 1-2: -Phoenix and Maya form a highly complimentary dynamic by instinct, with all the hallmarks of which repeated throughout every case in the series.
-Formation of a complementary ‘emotional support/needs’ dynamic (that caters to their idiosyncrasies and vulnerabilities of both character trait and past histories/traumas (some constructed retrospectively.)
-The formation of their foundational trust (belief) ‘contract’ – along with its 2nd tier of vow “I won’t abandon you"
-Phoenix and Maya form an immediate, highly productive, mutually supportive and empathetic connection (devoid of ‘teething problems’, ‘adjustments’ or communication confusion.)
-Phoenix and Maya can
ONLY achieve triumph over White’s injustice by their complementary dynamic together, they are literally
unable to when working alone (Phoenix also falls prey to White when trying to work alone, Maya must ‘miraculously’ save him)
-The context of Maya’s introduction and dynamic formed with Phoenix therein is
totally different to the later ‘stereotype teen-girl-assistant roles’.
-Maya isn’t some baggage-‘inheritance’ Mia left around for Phoenix to babysit along with ‘his’ office; it’s more along the lines that Mia instructs
her to adopt
Phoenix.
---
ONLY THE RECIPROCAL PARTNERSHIP DYNAMIC OVERCOMES WHITE It may superficially appear to follow the stereotypical ‘damsel in distress’ trope (that its allusion is invoked at all, as in the other key trope-subversion, 2-4, is just more ‘romance’ contextualising-subtext) but this soon morphs into a partnership altogether different as Maya’s character and autonomous action repeatedly turns this role stereotype on its head. Maya is in trouble. Maya can’t save herself. Maya can’t channel to save
herself, even her own life, has never channelled, ‘could never do something on that level’.
* -Phoenix
* So, you're a real, honest-
* to-goodness spirit medium?
* With E.S.P. and all that?
*
* -Maya
* Yes.
* ...In training.
*
* -Phoenix
* Well, can't you contact
* Mia's spirit, then?
*
* -Phoenix
* We can just ask
* her who killed her!
*
* -Maya
* ...!
*
* -Maya
* I-I'm sorry...
*
* -Maya
* I'm still in training.
*
* -Maya
* I couldn't do something
* on that level...
*
* -Phoenix
* (Hmm... I thought that
* would be too easy.)
* Phoenix
can save her – but only with his own incompetence/inexperience (confronting White) unintentionally ending up with himself on trial for murder. He acts as his own defense attorney – thinking he can save himself…. But – this is integral – he CAN’T. (And thus, passes out.)
-Edgeworth
The time has come for you
to admit your defeat!
-Edgeworth
You fought... honorably.
-Phoenix
(No more...)
-Phoenix
(I can't take this anymore...)
-Judge
Mr. Wright?
-Judge
Are you giving up?
-Phoenix
...
-Phoenix
Y-yes, Your Honor.
[…]
-Phoenix
...
-Phoenix
Oh, right...
-Phoenix
I lost the trial.
-Phoenix
I was... hallucinating.
This is just one aspect that marks the Maya–Phoenix dynamic as a partnership – instinctively so. Phoenix is probably touched by her tacit emotional support and goodwill (and thus, asks for her presence at the trial) but assumes she will be of no tangible help (which is
not condescending, as Maya’s subsequent ‘assistance’ is nothing short of miraculous to the not-already-desensitised.) Maya doesn’t need to be told how or when to help Phoenix. Maya shows continual
initiative throughout the case to assist him practically and emotionally. And when Phoenix’s defense fails, her urge to help him is so strong, it’s literally the catalyst that invokes her latent spiritual powers for the first time to channel!
-Mia
When you accepted your
defeat in court...
-Mia
It appears that was enough
of a shock to awaken
Maya's true powers.
[…]
-Mia
Now, I want you to listen
to me, Phoenix.
-Mia
Maya never gave up.
You can't either!
When acting alone, White would have sent Maya and Phoenix to their unjust deaths as Mia before them. Only the
reciprocal bond of mutual loyalty allows them to overcome the injustice and triumph over White – at least partially ‘avenging’ his long list of casualties as Mia’s life’s work had desired. The Phoenix-Maya
complimentary dynamic is
more than the sum of its parts. Compare and contrast to the UNcoincidenly similar Phoenix-‘Dollie’Iris ‘partnership’. Even after SEVEN MONTHS of supposed ‘true love’, no meaningful connection or communication is achieved – to disastrous and nearly-fatal results. Phoenix-Iris is a ‘partnership’ of few words – and so is Phoenix-Maya. But
unlike 3-1 Phoenix-Iris (seemingly stuck in incompatible diametrically opposite universes which neither can properly comprehend of empathise with) they are not needed. Phoenix’s empathy to Maya is
instinctive.
In this initial case, and every other, one can be locked up, passed out, kidnapped, feared dead, have no time to discuss in words – but the other can be counted on to have the unconsulted initiative to do something genuinely reciprocal to solving their plight (often with little concern to their own safety). Delivering the decisive evidence under any adverse circumstance, channellings, taking a taser, being in contempt of court, trying to cross a burning bridge, countless others…
As for emotional supports and short-comings, these are seldom discussed either – but
they don’t need to be (beyond occasional re-affirmations of the original grounds of their bond-of trust ‘contract’) . The partnership very clearly acts as both resolution and compensation to Phoenix and Maya’s insecurities from personality quirks and canonic past traumas/life histories. (It’s as if their dynamic was actually
designed to be their complimentary other half. Oh wait. IT
WAS!)
---
“I TRUST YOU (SO YOU TRUST ME TOO)” – THE BOND-‘CONTRACT’ IS INSTANTIATED But the bond-partnership
IS initiated, here in 1-2, by heartfelt and serious
words.
-Phoenix
Maya...
-Phoenix
I won't abandon you.
You can count on me.
-Maya
...
-Maya
That's so kind of you...
-Maya
*sniff*...
-Maya
...
-Phoenix
Well!
-Phoenix
Let's fight this one
and get you out of here!
-Maya
R-right!
Thank you!
-Phoenix
(Whew, she smiled at last.
She looks like an entirely
different person!)
-Phoenix
One last question...
You are innocent, right?
-Maya
Yes!
-Maya
And I trust you...
-Maya
So you trust me,
too, okay?
-Phoenix
It's a deal. It’s basal – but it’s the unshakable foundation of their entire relationship.
I trust you (so you trust me too.) I won’t abandon you. (This foundational principle later translates into such beliefs as ‘Maya is not an murder, it’s literally IMPOSSIBLE.’ ‘Maya did not jump off Dusky Bridge and abandon me at trial, it’s impossible’ ‘I believe in Nick as a person to do the ‘right’ thing (whatever that is) in 2-4 and, for that matter, 3-2, and am wiling to sacrifice even my life to do so’ etc.)
It’s worth reconsulting Phoenix’s ending musings in 3-5.
Phoenix:
(Even when the battle is over,
and the bonds that connect
us are severed...)
Phoenix:
(We always return...
Time and time again.)
Phoenix:
(Mia, Maya, Pearls,
Mr. Armando...)
Phoenix:
(...and Maya's mother, too...)
Phoenix:
(I learned that... from
all of them.)
It’s unclear whether Phoenix’s mention of ‘Maya’ is in the context of his own relationship or of her connections to her mother and Mia. But this is irrelevant as the Phoenix-Maya bond (formed in 1-2 and continuing onward) is unique among them. One bond in the series that no matter what the adversity, is
NEVER, even temporarily, successfully ‘severed’.
-Maya
You know what this means?
We're partners!
---
AN IMMEDIATE COMPELLING CONNECTION The death of his mentor is clearly shocking to Phoenix and an atrocity in which he would have emotional investment, but it seems he has been most captivated by something else that night. The ‘strange girl’ does little but faint and few words are exchanged – but already Phoenix’s mind is unusually set on
one thing.
-Phoenix
I was taken in for questioning
and didn't get out until the
next morning.
-Phoenix
My eyes were heavy...
but I couldn't sleep.
-Phoenix
I sat around, waiting for
visiting hours to begin at
the detention center.
-Phoenix
I had to talk to Maya
as soon as possible.
-- So set he can’t sleep despite exhaustion… and, unusually, it’s not
Mia on his mind. You would ‘
assume’ by
default that would be Phoenix’s motivator - but Mia simply
isn’t mentioned, it’s MAYA.
---
MAYA’S CANDID PRESENTATION –ONE TO WHICH PHOENIX INSTINCTIVELY AND EMPATHETICALLY CONNECTS Maya, from the moment we see her and throughout the games, is an intensely expressive character – open in her emotions, openly tearful (though not in the manner of, say, Iris…) when expressing genuine emotion, intensely determined in support of, well, Phoenix, though largely non-combative and not prone to grudges. (In some manners she resembles the openly tearful, overly-expressive, trusting, loyal Feenie of Phoenix’s less cynical youth; the fact ‘Feenie’ was constructed retrospectively just supports the argument the characters were written to have an empathetic dynamic.) It seems Maya’s openness (both in laying bare her family ‘shame’, questionable ‘occupation’ and open emotions) is something Phoenix is wired to connect to. It’s not a matter of ‘anybody who isn’t a jerk’ would act as such in that situation – it’s only Phoenix’s particular set of compatible idiosyncrasies of personality and history that mean he wouldn’t refuse to touch such a case (like every other defense attorney in the district.) Phoenix makes no secret he strongly empathises with Maya and her plight – even before he’s decided to ‘trust’ she is certainly innocent – due to his own past experiences and many other factors demonstrated by his actions which he does not intonate in words – he is clearly captivated somehow by Maya even from their brief interchange the night of the murder.
For purpose of writing 1-2 itself, this probably referred to the infamous ‘class trial’; but GS3, though retrospectively written, is definitely canonic of Phoenix’s past, so it can clearly be taken to refer to his experiences as ‘Feenie’ as well – the ‘Dollie’ nightmare of betrayal, abandonment by Iris, trial for murder, and Mia’s ‘rescue’ convincing him of being a defense attorney being the correct path to pursue from that moment on (rather than a vague childhood dream from which he was distracted.)
And the Maya we meet is intensely genuine. Far from her introduction being as a comedy sidekick cracking a burger joke (which is merely an auxiliary role) this is dead serious, Maya openly crying, not because she is a weak-willed crybaby, but because she is
bent over her sister’s murdered dead body, the gravity still greater since Mia is one of the very few victims in the series we actually knew and connected to pre-death. Maya is never superficial.
And when Maya is candid toward Phoenix in the detention centre, it’s NOT at all with the intent or assumption of manipulating his compassion or assistance. (Contrast to a certain scene in 3-1.) Maya doesn’t expect him to help her, certainly not in a meaningful manner, she asks the favour of relaying the message to Grossberg because there is no one else she can ask.
Maya isn’t ever a ‘Mia Lite’ – already she’s subverting the ‘wisdom’ and ‘advice’ of her sister to believe instead in
Phoenix and his abilities – an undying belief she maintains henceforth (Mia through the series, as here, being detached, cryptic and colder, even if she clearly does have strong positive affect toward Phoenix.)
---
PHOENIX’S MOTIVATIONS TAKING THE CASE – INDIVISIBLE EMPATHETIC CONNECTION TO MAYA In stark contrast to the ‘Dollie’ comparative tale, (with Dahlia’s deliberate and fictional spin to manipulate Phoenix,
UNcoincidently also in context of his potential aid in light of pending murder charges,) Maya’s personal PR marketing pitch is an unmitigated disaster. Way to go Maya, as a segeway to your ‘innocence of murder’ candidly laying bare your family shame, skeletons in the closet and the fact you yourself are one of a line of ‘spirit mediums’ openly derided by all (including the justice system) as ‘frauds’. It’s very probable Phoenix was sceptical of Maya and the Fey’s ‘channelling’ ability at this point in time, even if he is not tactless enough to explicitly say so, also notable that Mia had NEVER mentioned any of this family ‘heritage’ to Phoenix (
Phoenix: (I had no idea...).) so it’s clear it was not something of which she thought status-enhancing.
It’s important to note that there was really no reason or inherent responsibility to Phoenix himself helping Maya nor presuming her innocence. The mere fact she is ‘Mia’s Sister’ in no way disassociates her from potential guilt or involvement in the murder; sibling rivalry and family tensions are older than humanity and Phoenix and Maya had certainly never met. Phoenix had no ‘responsibility’ toward her or even to ‘resolving’ the mess. Phoenix’s onus as a nice guy helping her presuming her innocence (and any lingering responsibility to Mia) would have been more than fulfilled by taking the message to Grossberg - The fact Grossberg REFUSES to take her case would invoke valid warning flags, not pity, in most cases.
* -Phoenix
* I don't have time to argue
* with you anyway. I'll go
* look elsewhere.
*
* -Grossberg
* *grumble*... Think not.
*
* -Phoenix
* Huh? Did you say something?
*
* -Grossberg
* I think not, I said.
*
* -Phoenix
* Wh-what do you mean?
*
* -Grossberg
* I'm terribly, terribly sorry.
*
* -Grossberg
* But I'm afraid that no lawyer
* worth their salt will take
* on this particular case.
*
* -Grossberg
* Terribly sorry, m'boy.
*
* -Phoenix
* Why!?
*
* -Grossberg
* I...
* I cannot say.
*
* -Grossberg
* ...
Unlike some other cases, where Phoenix’s defense of the client is partially or wholly a vehicle to uncover the ‘truth’ of the case, Phoenix’s primary concern in the case is defending MAYA. Sure, he does have obvious investment in wanting to uncover Mia’s true murderer, but throughout the case, Maya, empathy with her and a desire to defend her is at the forefront of his outer and inner dialogue. Mia (and justice related to her killer) is barely mentioned as a motivator, Phoenix is most captured by the plight of Maya, with whom he has clearly formed an intense empathetic connection clearly denoted by both his conscious and subconscious thoughts and actions. . In several ‘options’ he’s not even sure of her innocence –but the connection he feels is so strong he’s determined to try to defend her anyway.
The first game featured a primitive ‘interactive’ mechanic of ‘choose-your-own adventure style choices at key points in ‘your’ relating to Maya. But no matter what ‘options’ the
player chooses at each 3-way-choice, none of them changes
PHOENIX’s attitude to Maya, if the player chooses the worst ‘cold/uncaring jerk’ seeming option it is often a more resounding statement of Phoenix’s concern or connection to Maya (and vice versa) than the ‘best’ option. For example:
***Go home**********************************
*
* -Phoenix
* (There's nothing left
* here for me to do...)
*
* -Phoenix
* (She'll be better off with
* a state-appointed lawyer.)
*
* -Phoenix
* I think I'd better
* get home now.
*
* -Maya
* Good-bye.
*
* -Phoenix
* It was a few days later when
* I found out how the story
* ended.
*
* -Phoenix
* The result of the trial
* was in the newspaper.
*
* -Phoenix
* "Guilty."
*
* -Phoenix
* I'll probably never
* meet her again.
*
* -Phoenix
* Did I make the
* right choice?
*
* -Phoenix
* Will I ever know?
*
* -Phoenix
* Mia... if you can hear
* me, please, tell me!
*
* -Phoenix
* ...
*
* -Phoenix
* Not! I can't let
* that happen!
*
* -Phoenix
* I'm not leaving here until
* she takes me as her lawyer!
*
* CONTINUE
*
********************************************
-Phoenix
I've made up my mind!
-Phoenix
I'm going to defend you
whether you want me to
or not!
-Maya
!
No matter what the player ‘chooses’, Phoenix doesn’t have a choice NOT to defend her!
-Maya
Why?
-Phoenix
Why?
Well...
OPTION:
***I don't know why*************************
*
* -Phoenix
* To be honest,
* I don't know.
*
* -Maya
* You don't know?
*
* -Phoenix
* (Is this girl sitting in
* front of me the killer?)
*
* -Phoenix
* (All the evidence
* seems to say "yes.")
*
* -Phoenix
* (But there's something
* about this whole thing
* that smells... fishy.)
*
* -Phoenix
* (That witness's strange
* behavior... was that
* all an act?)
*
* -Phoenix
* (And the way that lawyer
* refused to help out Maya...)
*
* -Phoenix
* (But more than all that,
* she has no one left
* to help her!)
*
* -Phoenix
* (Nothing is more sad,
* or more lonely than that.)
*
*
* -Phoenix
* (I know... I've been there.
* A long time ago.)
*
* -Phoenix
* (Why did I become a lawyer
* in the first place...?)
*
* -Phoenix
* (Because someone has to look
* out for the people who have
* no one on their side.)
*
* -Phoenix
* But the one thing I do know is...
-Phoenix
Maya...
-Phoenix
I won't abandon you.
You can count on me.
-Maya
Are you going to
be my attorney?
OPTION:
***Sorry, not a chance**********************
*
* -Phoenix
* (Maybe if I joke a bit
* she'll cheer up...)
*
* -Phoenix
* Hah hah!
* No way, Jose!
*
* -Phoenix
* Just kidding...
*
* -Maya
* ...
*
* -Maya
* ...
*
* -Maya
* ...
*
* -Phoenix
* (Eh heh. Whoops.
* That didn't go so well.)
*
* -Maya
* ...Heh...
*
* -Phoenix
* Huh?
*
* -Phoenix
* M-Maya...?
*
* -Phoenix
* Was that a... chuckle?
*
* -Maya
* What?
*
* -Maya
* N-no!
*
* -Maya
* ...
*
* -Maya
* It wasn't very
* believable, was it?
*
* -Phoenix
* (Not really...)
*
* -Maya
* I-I'm sorry!
*
* -Maya
* I just thought, since
* you'd made a joke...
*
* -Maya
* Please, don't mind me!
* You're doing just fine!
*
* -Phoenix
* (Who's trying to
* cheer up who here!?)
*
* -Maya
* ...
*
* -Maya
* I knew it.
*
* -Maya
* No one will believe me.
*
* -Phoenix
* What?
*
* -Maya
* Even you--when you found me
* in the office. You looked at
* me like I had done it!
*
********************************************
Phoenix’s ‘joke’ fails, so Maya tries to ‘help’ him by pretending to be amused – very interesting.
---
DEDICATION TO HELP IN ANY WAY – INCLUDING BEYOND KNOWN LIMITATIONS Maya (compare to Iris, 3-1) doesn’t abandon Phoenix to his ‘fate’ after she is set free. Maya is desperate to do anything, really
anything he asks, to help, with the intensity of dedication she shows to Phoenix from that point on in the series.
Maya
Mr. Wright, please tell me,
is there anything I can do?
-Phoenix
Um... well...
***Defend me in court***********************
*
* -Phoenix
* Alright, you can be my
* defense lawyer tomorrow!
*
* -Maya
* Alright!
*
* -Phoenix
* Huh?
*
* -Maya
* Leave it to me! I am Mia's
* sister, after all! Lawyership
* runs in our blood!
*
* -Phoenix
* (Wasn't it E.S.P. that
* ran in your blood...?)
*
* -Maya
* I'd better run to the
* bookstore and pick up a copy
* of "Law for Rookies."
*
********************************************
***Cheer me on in court*********************
*
* -Phoenix
* Well, you could cheer
* for me in court.
*
* -Maya
* Cheer for you?
* You mean... like a
* cheerleader?
*
* -Phoenix
* Huh? Um, yeah, like that.
*
* -Maya
* Alright!
* Leave it to me!
*
* -Phoenix
* Huh?
*
* -Maya
* I'd better go get a uniform
* and some pom-poms...!
*
********************************************
***Help me break out of here****************
*
* -Phoenix
* Right. Okay, listen up.
* I want you to help me break
* out of here!
*
* -Maya
* You mean... a jail break?
*
* -Phoenix
* Yeah. Tonight's our
* only chance!
*
* -Maya
* Alright!
*
* -Phoenix
* Huh?
*
* -Maya
* Oh, I'd better go get a
* hacksaw while the stores
* are still open.
*
* -Maya
* Oh, oh! And a rope ladder,
* and a getaway car!
* Can you drive?
********************************************
-Phoenix
...
-Phoenix
W-wait. Wait wait wait.
-Maya
What what what?
-Phoenix
I'm kidding! It was a joke!
-Maya
No way!
-Phoenix
No really, I was kidding.
But thanks. It's good to know
you're on my side.
-Phoenix
(And there really isn't
anything you can do
for me anyway...)
-Maya
But... but I can't just sit
here and do nothing!
-Maya
I've got to give that
man a piece of my mind!
-Phoenix
(Just a piece...?)
-Phoenix
Okay.
-Phoenix
Then, come to the
court tomorrow.
-Maya
O-okay! I'll be there!
-Maya
I'll show them
a thing or two!
Phoenix may be touched by her support, but he underestimates her, assuming she can’t do anything (not unreasonable or overly dismissive, given the sheer ‘unexpected’ method of helping.) This, as we can see, mirrors Maya’s
own initial (and reasonable) misgivings over
Phoenix’s ability to defend her (Mia’s advice) or believe her (nobody else does) before her trust was gained.
-Phoenix
(And there really isn't
anything you can do
for me anyway...)
-Maya
But... but I can't just sit
here and do nothing!
[…]
-Phoenix
Then, come to the
court tomorrow. With some bravado, he assumes he can defend himself, by himself.
-Maya
Your defense attorney isn't
even here yet! He's not...
-Phoenix
I'll be defending myself.
-Maya
Whaaaat!? And, naturally, MAYA must save him.
---
MAYA’S BELIEF IN PHOENIX – EVEN WHEN MIA DIDN’T BELIEVE IN PHOENIX Maya’s ‘in training’, and it’s clear her powers (at least ones strong enough to channel) haven’t actually emerged yet. In fact, as she explains to Phoenix, she can’t channel even to SAVE HER OWN LIFE to get information about the murder. Can’t channel to save her own life – but Maya can spontaneously catalyst her powers to save PHOENIX. Think of the significance of this.
Similarly, with Phoenix as both protagonist and competent lawyer later on, we tend to forget exactly how tenuous his position must have been at the time, lost and alone with the unexpected and shocking demise of his mentor after at tutorlage of exactly ONE trial – and the game takes great pains to remind both us, and Phoenix, of this, and rub in his face that even
Mia didn’t believe in him. He had potential, but only 3 years of further refining would a lawyer make… if he took a case, she’d assume he’d LOSE.
-Mia
"The only thing he's lacking
is... experience."
-Maya
Huh, sounds like it was fun!
-Maya
Well, I know who to go to if
I ever get into trouble now!
-Mia
"I don't know, Maya."
-Mia
"I think you might want
to wait... give him three
more years."
-Mia
"That is, unless you want
to be found guilty."
-Maya
That's what she said!
-Phoenix
...
-Maya
I-I'm sorry!
-Maya
I didn't mean to
trouble you...
-Phoenix
No, it's okay.
It's true, I guess.
Mia thought Phoenix had potential…. but wouldn’t have trusted him to defend Maya, declaring point-blank he WOULD lose. The relationship dynamic between Phoenix and Maya – from both reciprocations – is substantially different to the Phoenix<>Mia connection. Maya isn’t ever a ‘Mia Lite’ – already she’s subverting the ‘wisdom’ and ‘advice’ of her sister to believe instead in
Phoenix and his abilities – an undying belief she maintains henceforth (Mia through the series, as here, being detached, cryptic and colder, even if she clearly does have strong positive affect toward Phoenix.)
When they establish their ‘trust contract’, Maya is going directly against the advice of her expert sister – MIA – to believe in Phoenix and trust in his ability to defend her. The bond of trust is mutual (Phoenix ceases any speculation Maya might not be innocent – forever after!) – and remains, no matter what the claims or adversities, from that point on.
In the spirit of her original trust in his ability to defend her, Maya believes in Phoenix as a person most notably in 2-4 (where she believes in him as a person to do the ‘right’ thing, whatever that may mean for her, her life for sacrifice in his hands – Mia’s ‘belief’, as here, is more confined to watching and maybe steering the train wreck) and even 3-2 (where she trusts in his plan to take the Ron deLite case to get to the truth even if superficially it seems it is a ‘betrayal’ since he stole her urn – the ‘trust-exchange’ is repeated here, which brings a tear to Phoenix’s eye.)
Is obsessive loyalty just some dumb and endearing trait of Maya generally that she has ‘imprinted’ on Phoenix? Definitely
not, as Maya shows no such intense dedication and loyalty to anyone
else. Her relationship with Mia was strong – but she was pursuing a lifepath very different and separate to hers (and is negating her advice to trust Phoenix instead already). Her loyalty is not to Kurain or her mother (as evidenced by her lack of training and extended periods away.) Her loyalty is not to Pearl (they maintain a warm cousinly relationship, but Maya certainly has not legally adopted her, or much supervised her and Pearl remains living in Kurain outside of her visits whilst Maya remains around… Phoenix.) In fact, Maya is someone with confusing (and understandable) divided loyalties with regards to her family… but there is one person to whom her loyalty is NOT divisible, and the same could be said about him with regards to her. The Phoenix<>Maya unbreakable bond of trust is simply not shared with any other characters. Edgeworth, Phoenix feels, ‘betrays’ their bond of trust to the point he is ‘dead to him’ even when alive – though it is regained, it’s a professional relationship (though a deep friendship). Phoenix can trust Mia – but only to a point, as he observes, particularly starkly in 2-2 where Mia is not only throwing up psyche-locks, but protecting Morgan and her truths from Phoenix - even at risk to her own sister! And Mia’s assistance, though useful, is erratic and cryptic throughout the games.
Maya can always perform beyond her limitations to the next level – but only for Phoenix, not in context of
herself. The pattern starts here (her initial channelling catalyst to save his life, not being able to when it was her own at stake) but is repeated throughout the series. ALL her ‘Kurain Powers’ surface in context of Phoenix and her loyalty to him, rather than out of loyalty to Kurain/the Master position of which she is not abdicative but somewhat lukewarm/her mother/even Mia. She channels for Phoenix (not clients in Kurain), she only returns to train in Kurain to attain the power to return and help Phoenix, she insists on his presence in 2-2 as the ‘one thing’ she desires… Obsessive loyalty is not a Maya character trait, obsessive loyalty to Phoenix, it seems, is.
---
“I WON’T ABANDON YOU” – 2ND FACT OF PHOENIX-MAYA BOND ‘CONTRACT’ -Phoenix
Maya...
-Phoenix
I won't abandon you.
You can count on me.
-Maya
...
-Maya
That's so kind of you...
-Maya
*sniff*...
“I won’t abandon you" Misty’s abandonment of Maya would deeply affect any child, Mia has left her (for the city and now, death), and, of course, Grossberg and all other lawyers have just abandoned Maya to her ‘fate’. Phoenix is probably unaware (at least on a conscious level – his instinctive empathy may likely be more concrete) but this is precisely what Maya needs to hear at this point in time- as her tears and thanks confirm.
Many speculate Phoenix has his own ‘abandonment issues – and it certainly would be unsurprising given his past traumas such as the Dollie-Iris ‘abandonment’ and his (over)reactions and borderline psychological malfunctions to both Edgeworth leaving (‘choosing death – ‘betrayal’) and even Maya temporarily leaving to Kurain, which sends him into borderline clinical depression.
Thus this core facet in their bond ‘contract’, established here, is clearly compensating hence-unspoken but empathetically sensed vulnerabilities and needs.
In fact, it must have been intensely meaningful to Maya, as immediately after, the conversation continues with Maya signifying her belief in Phoenix – going against the expert advice of Mia!:
-Phoenix
Well!
-Phoenix
Let's fight this one
and get you out of here!
-Maya
R-right!
Thank you!
-Phoenix
(Whew, she smiled at last.
She looks like an entirely
different person!)
-Phoenix
One last question...
You are innocent, right?
-Maya
Yes!
-Maya
And I trust you...
-Maya
So you trust me,
too, okay?
-Phoenix
It's a deal. ---
MAYA’S PRACTICAL ASSISTANCE – NOT JUST A COMEDIC BIMBO -Judge
Very well. Mr. Wright,
you may begin your
cross-examination.
-Phoenix
Y-yes, Your Honor.
-Phoenix
(Cross-examine what...?)
-Phoenix
(I couldn't see a single
contradiction in that
testimony...)
...whoosh...
SMACK!
-Phoenix
(Hey! Maya just threw
something at me...)
-Phoenix
(What's this?)
-Phoenix
("When my sister couldn't
find any contradictions
in a witness's testimony")
-Phoenix
("she would bluff it and
press the witness on
every detail!")
-Phoenix
("The witness always slips
up and says something
wrong...")
-Phoenix
("It worked lots of times!")
-Phoenix
(Heh... I should have expected
Maya would know some of
her sister's tricks!)
-Phoenix
(Alright.
Let's give this a try!)
One of Phoenix’s strategies in, well, EVERY trial from then on? It may be the first case together, but already Maya is assisting Phoenix in the usual game mechanic/dynamic we see every case by providing ‘hints’ to case strategy, not to mention presenting him with critical/decisive evidence (it’s Maya who shows the initiative to insist on his having the recorded cell phone conversation, which is integral to taking out April May and uncovering the truth of the case; and although the key ‘turnabout’ evidence is really a product of Mia, it’s intrinsically tied up with Maya also – addressed to her, the reason SHE was arrested in the first place so the whole saga-White capture occurred as it did, and Mia would never have been able to ‘hint’ its significance if Maya hadn’t taken her powers to the next level to channel the first time, solely out of her pure desire to help Phoenix escape the murder charge.) Furthermore, she gives him the lead to ‘White’ in the first place.
---
NOT JUST A STEREOTYPICAL TEEN-GIRL-SIDEKICK-COMEDIC-FORMULA ROLE Maya’s detractors point to the later reused ‘formula-sidekick-role’ as a means to demote the importance of her association to Phoenix. But it was only from the DS-rerelease-only 1-5 onwards that ‘teen-girl-sidekick-to-protagonist’ was demoted to stereotypical and reused trope-‘role’. Maya was constructed as
MAYA, not someone to ‘fill’ a ‘formulatic reused ‘role’ the way later ‘assistants’ arguably were.
The major purpose of Ema, Kay, et al is to bounce off the protagonist for comedic purpose. Is this, then, the main purpose of Maya’s ‘accompanying’ of Phoenix, as a comedy duo?
NO! Unlike the other assistants, Maya’s main role is NOT as a ‘comedy sidekick’ as evidenced by the context of the Phoenix-Maya introduction case. The entirety of this case (and Phoenix and Maya’s association and partnership in it) is
DEAD SERIOUS and
DEVOID of any Phoenix-Maya comedy. It’s even more poignant as so early in the series, such events are far more shocking (and not the standard fare one comes to expect with murders and protagonists on trial every case.) Maya is established as a Partner to Phoenix in myriad other ways before any of the ‘comedy partner’ material ever surfaces (confined to a token scene at the end of the case.)
Contrast, also, to the Apollo-Trucy ‘meeting’ in 4-1. This, too, may have been a ‘serious case’, but Apollo and Trucy show no actual CONNECTION. In 4-1 itself, she remains as only a ‘strange mysterious girl’ who only gives him questionable (FORGED) ‘evidence’. The Apollo-Trucy ‘connection’ is also ‘real’, but rather executed by actual blood relationship (siblings) of which both remain oblivious – Phoenix and Maya’s is NOT. (The fact GS4 was fond of superficial ‘opposites’ adds fuel to the argument Phoenix and Maya’s relationship is
not ‘SIBLINGS’.)
---
MIA’S ‘WILL’ -Maya
See? Mia wrote me a letter.
-Maya
"Take care of Phoenix for me."
-Phoenix
Take care of... huh?
Maya’s detractors tend to assume Phoenix acquired Maya by virtue of Mia’s inheritance to him, with Phoenix as her ‘babysitter’. However, simple logic dictates this is not the case, if Mia had a will – which she surely did – her possessions such as the office and legal firm would be left to her only immediate family – ie.
MAYA – and there is likely no mention of Phoenix, even if they were close, a professional mentor whom he calls ‘Chief’ is hardly a ‘relationship which includes you as benefactor in their will’. It is clear. In effect,
Maya has ‘adopted’
PHOENIX.
-Maya
She means the office!
This office!
No she doesn’t.
-Maya
You know what this means?
We're partners! END