Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Powers Fan
Gender: None specified
Rank: Prosecutor
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2008 2:46 am
Posts: 703
Also, an interesting thing to note-at the end of the game, Lamiroir speaks of an accident, but one that took place ten years ago. This could be a typo, but what if it's not? Lamiroir regained her memory, but just what did she remember? Perhaps there are some dark secrets left still. And what about the Gramarye Miracle? Just what is the true nature of that, and what if it is somehow behind her accident?
What if the Miracle was stolen from the troupe that Thalassa's first husband was part of? I can't see her having been responsible, but it wouldn't be impossible. Perhaps Magnifi thought Apollo's dad was too close to figuring out what he was up to and killed him. The other troupe members also had some suspicions, and Thalassa came under fire. If we presume relations were bad between this troupe and Troupe Gramarye, then Thalassa leaving Apollo behind might make sense. Either she was afraid of how her father would treat the child or she wanted to spare him from that life.
"You just wish you could talk in Webdings."
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
TIN PIN SLAMMER TIME!
Gender: None specified
Rank: Desk Jockey
Joined: Sat Apr 25, 2009 5:09 am
Posts: 82
TheSteelSamurai wrote:
Zak plotting with Magnifi to kill Thalassa, regardless of any locks, wouldn't make much sense.
Why not?
TheSteelSamurai wrote:
Also, an interesting thing to note-at the end of the game, Lamiroir speaks of an accident, but one that took place ten years ago. This could be a typo, but what if it's not?
Trucy said she was five when her mum died. During the Mason system thingy.
TheSteelSamurai wrote:
If we presume relations were bad between this troupe and Troupe Gramarye, then Thalassa leaving Apollo behind might make sense. Either she was afraid of how her father would treat the child or she wanted to spare him from that life.
A Romeo and Juliet where Juliet remarries.
Please don't let my dragons die.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Powers Fan
Gender: None specified
Rank: Prosecutor
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2008 2:46 am
Posts: 703
Trucy was eight, wasn't she?O_o Wasn't it seven years before the game that her mother died?
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
TLDR Master
Gender: None specified
Rank: Desk Jockey
Joined: Wed May 06, 2009 4:55 am
Posts: 92
TheSteelSamurai wrote:
The reasons people have supplied just don't add up. Plus, there was no guarantee a plot wouldn't end in disaster.
Trucy was eight, wasn't she?O_o Wasn't it seven years before the game that her mother died?
Trucy was eight, wasn't she?O_o Wasn't it seven years before the game that her mother died?
Seven years from the game start was the State vs. Enigmar trial, that’s when Zak performed his vanishing act in court and left Trucy with Phoenix. Thalassa’s “accident” happened before that. 2015 according to the C-R timeline, so 10 years sounds about right.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
TIN PIN SLAMMER TIME!
Gender: None specified
Rank: Desk Jockey
Joined: Sat Apr 25, 2009 5:09 am
Posts: 82
Odrom wrote:
TheSteelSamurai wrote:
The reasons people have supplied just don't add up. Plus, there was no guarantee a plot wouldn't end in disaster.
Trucy was eight, wasn't she?O_o Wasn't it seven years before the game that her mother died?
Trucy was eight, wasn't she?O_o Wasn't it seven years before the game that her mother died?
Seven years from the game start was the State vs. Enigmar trial, that’s when Zak performed his vanishing act in court and left Trucy with Phoenix. Thalassa’s “accident” happened before that. 2015 according to the C-R timeline, so 10 years sounds about right.
What he said
Please don't let my dragons die.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Badass attorney
Gender: None specified
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Wed May 27, 2009 6:26 pm
Posts: 202
TheSteelSamurai wrote:
The other troupe members also had some suspicions, and Thalassa came under fire.
Hmm. Perhaps Thalassa knew too much and someone wanted her out of the picture. Maybe her own father. Messed up... But not impossible.
Also, the thing about Magnifi's performing rights... That pink letter thing. Phoenix wants Trucy to open it when the time comes. Surely that may just mean she has to wait until she's 18 or something similar... But what if there's something else, another reason? Valant felt strongly enough about those rights to consider killing Magnifi and framing Zak, and he ended up doing the framing stuff since Magnifi killed himself (assuming that's true...).
Urgh, I want GS5 already.
All Ace Attorney series breakdowns in order of appearance.
WARNING: This includes Gyakuten Kenji towards the end of the video!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7x38Jxeyp-k
WARNING: This includes Gyakuten Kenji towards the end of the video!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7x38Jxeyp-k
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
TIN PIN SLAMMER TIME!
Gender: None specified
Rank: Desk Jockey
Joined: Sat Apr 25, 2009 5:09 am
Posts: 82
General Luigi wrote:
Zak said he didn't shoot Thalassa, and no Psyche-locks appeared. Thus, he couldn't have knowingly and willingly shot her.
When Zak said that, he already had Psyche-locks over his heart. We all know that when people lie during an unlocking, nothing will happen.
Please don't let my dragons die.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Experimental Hydroxyacelunodosetrase
Gender: Female
Location: Sweet Home Alabama
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Thu Apr 16, 2009 12:48 pm
Posts: 1689
I rest my case
Carly. 19. Ravenclaw. Hell's Belle.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
TIN PIN SLAMMER TIME!
Gender: None specified
Rank: Desk Jockey
Joined: Sat Apr 25, 2009 5:09 am
Posts: 82
Thalassa could have been the best mother in the world, or a complete bitch.
Valant, we know a little more about, but still, he could well have been acting the whole time. Like Matt, the magatama couldn't pick up that he was evil, just that he wasn't lying.
Not to mention Zak seems to be conflicting between good and bad. First, he is a jerk and leaves Trucy with Nick, then gives her the performance rights. Then, he accuses Nick of cheating, and is a sore loser, then bails Valant out. If you ask me, he acts like he has a good and bad side. Another Matt Enguarde who just happened not to do anything this time.
Please don't let my dragons die.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Taking it, one step at a time.
Gender: None specified
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 12:58 am
Posts: 157
It would make much more better sense to say that either Zak or Valant were stupid enough to put a real bullet in their guns(if they did, I really don't remember how that trick works, or if they mentioned if they used real bullets for that trick), fire away, and BANG! They get Thalassa right were it hurts....
Okay, what really doesnt make sense, as some poeple in this thread have pointed out, is why would Magnifi go through all that trouble to cover it up? If he was really involved with covering it up, as Zak or Valant, mentioned he was...(I do remember a part of the game when Valant, or maybe Zak, said that Magnifi tried to cover it up) One thing everyone has made a point to point out, is that Magnifi is just a jerk, and put the life of his daughter after the reputation of the troupe, but it could also mean that Thalassa appeared dead to them, and the last thing Magnifi wanted was his two pupils to go to jail for accidentilly killing his daughter...of course, considering how much of a jerk he was being with Zak and Valant after that accident, although considering what happened to his daughter, made him go all jerk mode...But, that's just me.
You were born on the same day as your birthday, right?
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Experimental Hydroxyacelunodosetrase
Gender: Female
Location: Sweet Home Alabama
Rank: Ace Attorney
Joined: Thu Apr 16, 2009 12:48 pm
Posts: 1689
Any one of them could've done it really.
Carly. 19. Ravenclaw. Hell's Belle.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Taking it, one step at a time.
Gender: None specified
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 12:58 am
Posts: 157
You were born on the same day as your birthday, right?
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Ugh. Lawyers.
Gender: None specified
Location: Boston
Rank: Medium-in-training
Joined: Wed May 21, 2008 11:08 pm
Posts: 403
Spoiler: 4-4
Uhm, well, thats me. Pretty poor excuse but I'll stick to it! xD
Courtroom Romance Afficianado || Talk to me about your fav rarepairs
Apollo Justice Deserves Better
Next Turnabout Boston meetup ---> n/a
Apollo Justice Deserves Better
Next Turnabout Boston meetup ---> n/a
Next Cons for 2016:
NYCC
AAC
Katsucon [??]
Anime Boston
NYCC
AAC
Katsucon [??]
Anime Boston
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
In Justice We Trust
Gender: Male
Location: Southern California
Rank: Admin
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 6:31 pm
Posts: 4215
book__wyrm wrote:
When Zak said that, he already had Psyche-locks over his heart. We all know that when people lie during an unlocking, nothing will happen.
Strange... I could have sworn he said it after being unlocked. No matter. Okay, so it is possible that he knowingly and willingly shot Thalassa. However, that raises an important issue: Trucy. We've seen her ability, and it's clear that she's no fool. If Zak knowingly and willingly shot Thalassa, I'd think he'd give off a signal that Trucy would pick up on. He wouldn't be able to keep a secret like that from her. Yes, he disappeared from Trucy's life, but she had plenty of time before then to notice the twitch.
I'll always love you, Max.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Taking it, one step at a time.
Gender: None specified
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 12:58 am
Posts: 157
Quote:
Strange... I could have sworn he said it after being unlocked. No matter. Okay, so it is possible that he knowingly and willingly shot Thalassa. However, that raises an important issue: Trucy. We've seen her ability, and it's clear that she's no fool. If Zak knowingly and willingly shot Thalassa, I'd think he'd give off a signal that Trucy would pick up on. He wouldn't be able to keep a secret like that from her. Yes, he disappeared from Trucy's life, but she had plenty of time before then to notice the twitch.
Well, it really could be possible that he disappeared primarly for that small reason, but then again, Zak could just be feeling guilty over the accident...or maybe he felt he was partially responisble and couldnt resolve to see his daughter face to face(concidering her ability and all), but, since we know little to nothing of their relationship outside of Phoenix's last trial, we really won't know.
You were born on the same day as your birthday, right?
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
TIN PIN SLAMMER TIME!
Gender: None specified
Rank: Desk Jockey
Joined: Sat Apr 25, 2009 5:09 am
Posts: 82
General Luigi wrote:
book__wyrm wrote:
When Zak said that, he already had Psyche-locks over his heart. We all know that when people lie during an unlocking, nothing will happen.
Strange... I could have sworn he said it after being unlocked. No matter. Okay, so it is possible that he knowingly and willingly shot Thalassa. However, that raises an important issue: Trucy. We've seen her ability, and it's clear that she's no fool. If Zak knowingly and willingly shot Thalassa, I'd think he'd give off a signal that Trucy would pick up on. He wouldn't be able to keep a secret like that from her. Yes, he disappeared from Trucy's life, but she had plenty of time before then to notice the twitch.
No, I'm pretty sure he said that before the second lock broke. and remember, Trucy didn't have a bracelet to tell her he was lying. And she loved her daaddy, and also, at the age of 8, she still thought her mommy had just disapeared. He had never told her she was dead.
Please don't let my dragons die.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Taking it, one step at a time.
Gender: None specified
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 12:58 am
Posts: 157
Quote:
No, I'm pretty sure he said that before the second lock broke. and remember, Trucy didn't have a bracelet to tell her he was lying. And she loved her daaddy, and also, at the age of 8, she still thought her mommy had just disapeared. He had never told her she was dead.
It could be that Trucy was not yet familiar with the concept of her power, and you have to remember that her mother disappeared when she was like, what? Five years old, or six? Also, saying to trucy that her mother just 'disappeared' could be rather true, as neither Zak nor Valant saw her after the accident, therefore, creating a sort of truth within the whole thing...I'm not too sure about this last thing, since I don't remember who said this in the game...
And as for the lock thing, I do remember that Valant(from the past) mentioned the accident to Nick, before the latter told it to Zak, or something like that...because if I recall correctly, breaking the lock for Zak was for the identidy of Apollo, not about the accident or Trucy...but, of course, my memory fails since I can no longer play my AJ game.
You were born on the same day as your birthday, right?
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
TIN PIN SLAMMER TIME!
Gender: None specified
Rank: Desk Jockey
Joined: Sat Apr 25, 2009 5:09 am
Posts: 82
lonelywerewolf14 wrote:
Quote:
No, I'm pretty sure he said that before the second lock broke. and remember, Trucy didn't have a bracelet to tell her he was lying. And she loved her daaddy, and also, at the age of 8, she still thought her mommy had just disapeared. He had never told her she was dead.
It could be that Trucy was not yet familiar with the concept of her power, and you have to remember that her mother disappeared when she was like, what? Five years old, or six? Also, saying to trucy that her mother just 'disappeared' could be rather true, as neither Zak nor Valant saw her after the accident, therefore, creating a sort of truth within the whole thing...I'm not too sure about this last thing, since I don't remember who said this in the game...
And as for the lock thing, I do remember that Valant(from the past) mentioned the accident to Nick, before the latter told it to Zak, or something like that...because if I recall correctly, breaking the lock for Zak was for the identidy of Apollo, not about the accident or Trucy...but, of course, my memory fails since I can no longer play my AJ game.
No, I think Zak's locks were about the Gramarye secret.
Please don't let my dragons die.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Badass attorney
Gender: None specified
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Wed May 27, 2009 6:26 pm
Posts: 202
All Ace Attorney series breakdowns in order of appearance.
WARNING: This includes Gyakuten Kenji towards the end of the video!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7x38Jxeyp-k
WARNING: This includes Gyakuten Kenji towards the end of the video!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7x38Jxeyp-k
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Taking it, one step at a time.
Gender: None specified
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 12:58 am
Posts: 157
You were born on the same day as your birthday, right?
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Just a random passerby
Gender: Male
Location: Hyrule
Rank: Prosecutor
Joined: Sun Mar 16, 2008 4:42 pm
Posts: 623
I think there's a good possibility that Magnifi himself shot Thalassa. Since Magnifi knows all about the trick, he would know how to shoot her without anyone knowing. He could put a real bullet in of the other bullets without Zak or Valant knowing. Or he could've had another gun secretly crafted and shoot her during the trick. There's no doubt about it, Magnifi definitely had the means to do it. Motive... is a little harder to prove, seeing how Thalassa is his daughter. But Magnifi could have been angry about Thalassa leaving the Troupe. Also, he could've found out about Apollo, or Spark Brushel could've told him about Apollo, and got real angry at her about it and/or she didn't tell her own father about Apollo. Not to mention that she abandoned Apollo, maybe Magnifi didn't like it that she abandoned him. Plus, he could blame it on Zak and Valant and use it to force Zak and Valant to perform Magnifi's tricks. I know it's a stretch, but one that could've happened.
Keep in mind that this is only a theory. Zak or Valant had the means to do it too. Valant had a motive to do it too, though I'm not sure Zak had one. I guess he could have had one.
Re: Thoughts on Thalassa*SPOILERS*
Taking it, one step at a time.
Gender: None specified
Rank: Decisive Witness
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 12:58 am
Posts: 157
Quote:
I commented on this in another thread, but since this one is more to the point, I should post it here also.
I think there's a good possibility that Magnifi himself shot Thalassa. Since Magnifi knows all about the trick, he would know how to shoot her without anyone knowing. He could put a real bullet in of the other bullets without Zak or Valant knowing. Or he could've had another gun secretly crafted and shoot her during the trick. There's no doubt about it, Magnifi definitely had the means to do it. Motive... is a little harder to prove, seeing how Thalassa is his daughter. But Magnifi could have been angry about Thalassa leaving the Troupe. Also, he could've found out about Apollo, or Spark Brushel could've told him about Apollo, and got real angry at her about it and/or she didn't tell her own father about Apollo. Not to mention that she abandoned Apollo, maybe Magnifi didn't like it that she abandoned him. Plus, he could blame it on Zak and Valant and use it to force Zak and Valant to perform Magnifi's tricks. I know it's a stretch, but one that could've happened.
Keep in mind that this is only a theory. Zak or Valant had the means to do it too. Valant had a motive to do it too, though I'm not sure Zak had one. I guess he could have had one.
I think there's a good possibility that Magnifi himself shot Thalassa. Since Magnifi knows all about the trick, he would know how to shoot her without anyone knowing. He could put a real bullet in of the other bullets without Zak or Valant knowing. Or he could've had another gun secretly crafted and shoot her during the trick. There's no doubt about it, Magnifi definitely had the means to do it. Motive... is a little harder to prove, seeing how Thalassa is his daughter. But Magnifi could have been angry about Thalassa leaving the Troupe. Also, he could've found out about Apollo, or Spark Brushel could've told him about Apollo, and got real angry at her about it and/or she didn't tell her own father about Apollo. Not to mention that she abandoned Apollo, maybe Magnifi didn't like it that she abandoned him. Plus, he could blame it on Zak and Valant and use it to force Zak and Valant to perform Magnifi's tricks. I know it's a stretch, but one that could've happened.
Keep in mind that this is only a theory. Zak or Valant had the means to do it too. Valant had a motive to do it too, though I'm not sure Zak had one. I guess he could have had one.
It could be true...although I have to wonder...didnt they use real bullets for their act, or something of that sort? (I keep on forgetting
) Your theory, too, seems to hold water, but, its really hard to tell if Apollo really was abondoned or not, because, that too is sort of a theory around here too. That guy is just as full of secrets just as much as his own mother is.
You were born on the same day as your birthday, right?
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 23 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum
News
Site map
SitemapIndex
RSS Feed